Why don’t we eat insects? What archaeology can tell us about the future of food

When we talk about the foods of the future, insects regularly appear on the list. They are increasingly discussed as an alternative source of protein that could form part of more sustainable food systems. But there’s something slightly odd about calling insects 'alternative' protein - humans have been eating them for thousands of years! In my new paper, Edible insects as heritage foods: towards an archaeology of alternative proteins for food sustainability, published in World Archaeology, I explore what archaeology can tell us about the long history of eating insects, and what that history might contribute to current debates about sustainable food.

The archaeological evidence is surprisingly diverse. We can find insects directly in human coprolites, preserved faeces that contain remnants of foods that people actually consumed. At Paisley Caves in Oregon, for example, coprolites dating to the Younger Dryas and early Holocene contain evidence for the consumption of Jerusalem crickets and June beetles alongside plants and small animals. Elsewhere in the Americas, coprolites contain grasshoppers, bees and wasps.

There are other kinds of evidence too. Around 1,000 Rocky Mountain locusts were found in a cache at Crypt Cave in Nevada, while microscopic remains on a grindstone from Cloggs Cave in Australia show that Bogong moths were being cooked and ground around 2,000 years ago. Chemical residues can provide evidence for honey exploitation, while developing biomolecular approaches offer further ways of identifying insect consumption when recognisable remains have disappeared.

So why don’t insects feature more prominently in archaeological accounts of food?

Part of the problem is preservation. Bones, pottery and stone tools survive extremely well, whereas insects and other fragile food remains are much easier to miss. Archaeology has traditionally placed a lot of emphasis on the most visible evidence, particularly large animal bones, domesticated species and major crops. Even when insect remains are recovered, they may be interpreted as environmental evidence, pests or contamination rather than as food. The evidence we see and recognise shapes the stories we tell about past diets. Coprolites in particular give us a rather different perspective, showing just how diverse human diets could be and revealing foods that can be almost invisible through more conventional archaeological evidence.

There is another bias to consider too, and that is our own ideas about what counts as food. Eating insects remains part of longstanding food traditions in many parts of the world, including many parts of Asia, Africa and Latin America, including grasshoppers in Mexico and Uganda, caterpillars and termites across sub-Saharan Africa, and bamboo worms in Thailand. Rather than thinking about insects simply as a futuristic protein source, my paper suggests that we can also understand them as heritage foods, with histories of production, preparation and consumption stretching back generations and, in some cases, thousands of years. Attitudes towards eating insects have not been constant in Europe either. Classical and historical sources document the consumption of insects including cicadas, grubs and locusts. What seems strange or unacceptable to one society can be perfectly ordinary to another. One of the most interesting things I read about when researching this paper, is casu marzu, a traditional Sardinian cheese produced through the activity of cheese-fly larvae (Piophila casei), an example of insects continuing to form part of European culinary heritage. This really is a worldwide phenomenon.

And this is where I think archaeology has something particularly interesting to contribute to discussions about sustainable food; instead of presenting insect protein as something technologically new and culturally alien, archaeology shows us that humans have drawn on a much wider range of foods than modern Western diets might suggest. So perhaps the interesting question isn’t simply how can we persuade people to eat insects, but to think about how and why did we come to think that insects weren’t food in the first place?

The paper argues for an archaeology of alternative proteins, bringing together archaeological, biomolecular and taphonomic evidence while thinking critically about how our own cultural assumptions influence what we recognise as food in the archaeological record. Perhaps archaeology’s contribution to food sustainability isn’t simply to tell us what people ate in the past. It can also remind us that ideas about what is edible, normal and desirable are culturally constructed and have changed through time. And if they have changed before, they can change again...

Comments